I. Introduction

With each passing year, more transgender Americans have come out about their gender identity and sexual orientations.1 This stems from a growing awareness of the complexities of gender identity. Naturally, the discourse surrounding transgenderism has broadened and intensified, with many feeling strongly for or against deviating from one’s assigned sex. One point of contention is whether transgender people, particularly transgender women, should be allowed to play on school sports teams aligning with their gender (not sex) due to factors like fairness, safety, and the legitimacy of transgenderism. Many lawmakers who oppose transgenderism have supported and/or proposed harmful bills preventing transgender people’s participation in these sports teams. While some concerns over transgender people playing on teams of their self-identified gender come from valid concerns, the legislation to prevent it is invasive, discourages both transgender and cisgender athletes from participating in sports, and may conflict with constitutional freedoms despite Supreme Court rulings.

II. The Legal Landscape

A. Legislative Discussion

27 states have legislation prohibiting transgender youth from participating in sports in alignment with their gender identity, forcing them to participate on the sports team designated for their sex assigned at birth.2 Seven states restrict or prohibit transgender men from participating on male teams while all current legislation forbids transgender women’s participation on female teams.3 Some states have had stalled or failed bills, while voters in others are facing related ballot initiatives this November.4

In 2023, after a three-year-long battle between the legislature and the governor, Kansas lawmakers passed the Fairness in Women's Sports Act, banning transgender girls from participating on female sports teams.5 State Governor, Laura Kelly, had vetoed the bill thrice before it was passed, explaining that it would harm students’ mental health, and signal that the state is more dedicated to creating unneeded, “divisive legislation.”6 The bill mandates that all individual sports teams of postsecondary and public institutions be classified by sex, or be coed.7 Teams specifically for female athletes may not include biologically male students.8 Male teams are not restricted.9 Idaho enacted a nearly identical law three years prior.10 Idaho’s law specifies that, if a student’s sex is questioned, they will be required to undergo a “physical examination” by a physician, verifying the “student’s reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or” testosterone levels.”11 Genetic and hormone testing can be costly, forcing families to opt for the genital exam. Washington’s voters will be facing a ballot initiative (I-638) this November similar to these two laws, except that all female student-athletes, both cisgender and transgender, will be required to verify their sex through these means.12

Pressing concerns emerge from aforementioned pieces of legislation. The genital exams are not only unnecessary, but discouraged by “all major organizations, including the AAFP, the AAP and the USPSTF,” and unsupported by “clinical guidelines,” says family physician Madie Gore in response to I-638. Apprehension towards the exams is reasonable considering their intrusive nature, and how they may enable abuse by healthcare providers.13 A well-known example is how USA Gymnastics doctor Larry Nassar sexually abused female athletes for decades before his 2023 conviction.14 Nassar had easy access to his victims, as will other healthcare providers under I-638. Such invasive examinations deter cisgender athletes from engaging in their sports altogether, hindering the significant progress made in women’s sports since Title IX’s implementation.15

Charlie Baker, president of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), said that he knows of “fewer than 10 transgender athletes who currently compete in college sports.”16 Interestingly, the NCAA’s Board of Governors would vote to ban biological males from their female teams, highlighting the division posed by this issue.17 This is not to delegitimize the issue at-large, but rather to highlight that there are more pressing issues in women’s sports, such as abuse from coaches and the media, that legislators neglect.

B. Judicial Battles and Constitutionality

Constitutional and legal questions have been raised as a consequence of trans-exclusionary legislation.

Idaho’s law was challenged by “Lindsay Hecox, a transgender woman and student at Boise State University.”18 Hecox argued that the state’s act violated constitutional rights, namely the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause.19 West Virginia’s law, which came about a year later, was challenged by B.P.J., who has identified as female since third grade.20 Her and her mother asserted that B.P.J.’s exclusion violated the Equal Protection Clause, and Title IX, which prohibits sex-based discrimination in “federally funded education programs.”21 Both cases made it to the Supreme Court, and were decided together. In a 6-3 decision, the court ruled that sex-based eligibility for female sports teams is permitted under both Title IX, and the Fourteenth Amendment.22 According to Justice Thomas, “transgender status is not a ‘suspect class’ (a legal category commanding heightened judicial protection)” and therefore laws that affect them are subject to rational basis review, the most lenient form of Constitutional review, instead of intermediate scrutiny, the second strictest.23 Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Brown Jackson agreed with the Title IX ruling, but not the equal protection one due to an erroneously resolved factual dispute regarding whether or not transgender girls who never experienced puberty had an athletic advantage.24 Despite the ruling otherwise, some argue that trans-exclusionary policies conflict because individuals are grouped and penalized because of their sex.

The bans may violate the First Amendment freedom of religion.25 Although religion is not outwardly used to justify the bans, their creation is arguably guided by religious principles. Secular language focusing on factors like biological differences and fairness is strategically used in legislation to evade constitutional scrutiny while the true motivations are rooted in religious convictions.

III. Argument Conflicts, and Consequences

The widely-held belief is that transgender women outperform cisgender women because they are biologically male. In reality, however, existing research on the athleticism of transgender women is complex, and conflicting. A study published in The British Journal of Sports Medicine found that transgender women possessed “higher absolute handgrip” strength than cisgender women, but lower than cisgender men.26 However, transgender women scored lower than cisgender women across several metrics, including “relative jump height.”27 Some supporters of transgender women in sports argue that hormone therapy can offset physiological differences, as did B.P.J., who started taking “puberty blockers and estrogen” as male puberty began.28 The findings of other studies contradict this claim. A critical review by Alison Heather, a professor at the University of Otago, highlights how “testosterone drives much of the enhanced athletic performance of males through in utero, early life, and adult exposure,” and that testosterone results in “anatomical sex differences” that are irreversible even with estrogen therapy.29 These conflicts contribute to the debate surrounding transgender women in sports because both sides use them as core arguments, but productive discourse is difficult when facts cannot be agreed upon.

The exclusion of transgender people in sports has countless social ramifications that intensifies the oppression they face. The nature of current policy can appear as a collective punishment for cisgender athletes. I-638 is a prime example of legislation with extensive privacy violations.30 Resentment for these policies is directed towards the transgender community rather than lawmakers, effectively antagonizing the already marginalized group. Constant antagonization, and ostracization is highly detrimental to the mental health of transgender people. According to the national Youth Risk Survey from 2023, “transgender and questioning students experienced a higher prevalence of violence, poor mental health, suicidal thoughts and behaviors,” and “an estimated 40% of transgender and questioning students were bullied at school.”31 The violence that happens in schools is symptomatic of larger transphobic sentiment that is exacerbated by misplaced blame.

IV. Conclusion

Policies and proposals meant to promote fairness in women's sports appear to do more harm than good. The legislation created to exclude transgender people from athletics is an invasion of privacy, encroaches on key constitutional rights, and worsens the quality of life for this marginalized population. There is little evidence that can be used to conclusively determine whether or not transgender people have an athletic advantage over cisgender people. Policymakers ought to refrain from passing intrusive laws solely to police such a small group of people under the guise of equality.

Footnotes

Esther L. Meerwijk & Jae M. Sevelius, Transgender Population Size in the United States: a Meta-Regression of Population-Based Probability Samples, 107 Am. J. Pub. Health. e1, e1 (2017) Elana Redfield, The Impact of Transgender Sports Participation Bans on Transgender People in the US 1 (2025) [hereinafter Redfield 2025]; Joshua Arrayales & Elana Redfield, The Impact of 2025 State Anti-Transgender Legislation on Youth 13 (2026) [hereinafter Arrayles & Redfield 2026] Damali Ramirez Map: Which States Ban Transgender Athletes' Sports Participation? KOAT Action News 7 (Jul. 16, 2026); Arrayles & Redfield 2026 at 13, supra note 2 Claire Wang, ‘Invasive and Extreme’: Doctors Fight Anti-Trans Measure Requiring Genital Exams for Student Athletes, The Guardian (Oct. 21, 2026) [hereinafter Wang 2026] John Hanna, Kansas Bans Transgender Athletes From Women's, Girls' School Sports, PBS News (Apr. 5, 2023) [Hereinafter Hanna 2023] Hanna 2023, supra note 5; Governor’s Veto Message on H.B. 2238, Kan. Legis. Info (2023) Kan. Stat. Ann. § 60-5603 (2023) Id. Id. Idaho Code §§ 33-6201 to -6206 (2020) Id. § 33-6203 Initiative Measure No. IL26-638, Ballotpedia (last visited Oct. 29, 2026) 100+ Doctors and Other Medical Providers Issue Statement Opposing IL26-001 and IL26-638, No Hate in WA State (Aug. 24, 2026) Wang 2026, supra note 4 Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act of 2023, H.R. Rep. No. 118-35, at 19 (2023-2024) Brooke Migdon, NCAA President Says There are ‘Less than 10’ Transgender Athletes in College Sports, The Hill (Dec. 18, 2024) National Collegiate Athletic Association, NCAA Announces Transgender Student-Athlete Participation Policy Change, NCAA (Feb. 6, 2025) Little v. Hecox, Oyez (last visited Oct 29, 2026) [Hereinafter Little v. Hecox] Id. West Virginia v. B.P.J., Oyez (last visited Oct 29, 2026) [Hereinafter West Virginia v. B.P.J.] Id. Little v. Hecox West Virginia v. B.P.J. Id. U.S. Const. amend. I Blair Hamilton et al. Strength, Power and Aerobic Capacity of Transgender Athletes: a Cross-sectional Study 11 Brit. J. Sports Med. 586, 586 (2024) Id. West Virginia v. B.P.J, supra note 18 Alison K. Heather, Transwoman Elite Athletes: Their Extra Percentage Relative to Female Physiology, 19 Int'l J. Envtl. Rsch. & Pub. Health 1, 18 (2022) Wang 2026, supra note 2 Nicolas A. Suarez et al., Disparities in School Connectedness, Unstable Housing, Experiences of Violence, Mental Health, and Suicidal Thoughts and Behaviors Among Transgender and Cisgender High School Students — Youth Risk Behavior Survey, United States, 2023 73 Morb. Mortal. Wkly. Rep. 50, 50 (2024)