I. Introduction

Recent attempts to display the Ten Commandments in classrooms have reinvigorated the debate over religion in public schools. In 2025, Texas enacted Senate Bill 10, requiring public elementary and middle schools to display the Ten Commandments in a prominent location in classrooms across the state. Similar legislation in Louisiana and Arkansas has sparked nationwide debate over the separation of church and state. These laws raise a fundamental constitutional problem: Can the government require public schools to display religious scripture without violating the First Amendment?

In 1980, the Supreme Court struck down a comparable Kentucky law. However, its subsequent rejection of the Lemon test in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District (2022) has complicated the analysis. The Fifth Circuit’s 2026 decision in Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District raises the question of whether lower courts can treat established Supreme Court precedent as obsolete when the Court changes its constitutional framework.

II. Shift in Constitutional Doctrine

In Stone v. Graham (1980), the Supreme Court considered a Kentucky statute requiring the Ten Commandments to be posted in public school classrooms. Although the displays were privately funded and included a statement regarding the historical significance of the commandments, the Court held that the law violated the Establishment Clause. Applying the Lemon v. Kurtzman test, the Court decided that the statute lacked a genuine secular legislative purpose.

More than four decades later, Kennedy v. Bremerton School District changed the Establishment Clause jurisprudence. The Supreme Court abandoned the Lemon test and its endorsement-test offshoot, instead directing courts to interpret the Establishment Clause through historical understandings. The decision showed that the government does not inherently violate the Constitution only by allowing religious expression in public settings.

States defending the Ten Commandments legislation relied on this shift, arguing that the Commandments historical connection to American law and civic traditions, reflected in works such as William Blackstone’s Commentaries on the Laws of England, may support the argument that religion influenced the development of American legal institutions.

However, the distinction between allowing individuals to freely express their religion and requiring government-sponsored religious displays remains important. Kennedy concerned a public school coach’s personal religious observance, whereas Stone addressed a state law mandating religious displays in classrooms.

This distinction raises the question of whether abandoning the Lemon test eliminates Stone’s precedential force, or whether lower courts must follow its holding until the Supreme Court expressly overrules it?

III. The Fifth Circuit’s Decision: Nathan and Cribbs Ringer

In Rabbi Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District, families from diverse religious and nonreligious backgrounds challenged S.B. 10 under the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses, arguing that mandatory displays promoted a particular religious perspective and interfered with parents’ ability to direct their children’s religious upbringing. The Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, ruled on April 21, 2026, that S.B. 10 did not violate either clause. The majority concluded that Stone’s secular-purpose analysis could no longer control because the Supreme Court had abandoned the Lemon framework. Instead, the court examined whether the law resembled historical forms of religious establishment, such as government-compelled worship or official control over religious doctrine. Finding no comparable features, the majority rejected the constitutional challenges This reasoning raises a concerning question about vertical stare decisis, which generally requires lower courts to follow Supreme Court holdings even when later decisions undermine their reasoning. Although the majority considered Stone no longer controlling because its analysis depended on the abandoned Lemon test, critics argue that the Supreme Court’s rejection of a legal test does not automatically invalidate earlier decision applying it. The related case, Cribbs Ringer v. Comal Independent School District, also challenges Texas S.B. 10. Unlike adults encountering religious monuments in public spaces, elementary school students attend classrooms where displays are difficult to avoid. Importantly, exposure to religious material is not itself unconstitutional coercion, courts must consider whether the government’s decision to require that material changes its constitutional significance.

IV. Free Exercise, Parental Rights, Religious Pluralism

The controversy also raises questions about religious freedom and parental authority. The families challenging S.B. 10 argued that government-mandated displays interfere with their ability to guide their children’s religious development. The Fifth Circuit rejected these claims, reasoning that the law did not require students to recite the commandments, affirm their religious authority, or participate in religious observances. Nevertheless, the distinction between requiring students to practice a religion and requiring them to encounter government-selected scripture deserves careful consideration. A classroom display may not compel worship, but it can communicate which religious traditions the state considers worthy of special recognition. The wording of the mandated displays also raises questions regarding religious pluralism. Jewish, Catholic, and Protestant traditions differ in how they divide and enumerate the Ten Commandments. Requiring one version therefore raises concerns about whether the state privileges a particular religious interpretation over others. These concerns do not independently establish a Constitutional violation, but they reinforce the importance of examining the government’s role in selecting and displaying religious texts.

V. Conclusion

The Fifth Circuit’s decision in Nathan demonstrates the significant consequences of the Supreme Court’s shift from the Lemon test to history and tradition. The majority conclusion that Stone was no longer controlling allowed Texas to require the Ten Commandments displayed in public school classrooms. Yet the decision raises an important question about the authority of lower courts to determine when Supreme Court precedent has been displaced. Ultimately, the debate is not about whether the Ten Commandments influenced American legal history. It is about whether that history justifies government-mandated religious displays in public schools today. As courts continue applying the history-and-tradition standard, they must determine how historical practices interact with the First Amendment’s protections for religious freedom, particularly in classrooms serving students from diverse religious and nonreligious backgrounds.

Footnotes

1. Abington School District v. Schempp, 374 U.S. 203 (1963). 2. Agostini v. Felton, 521 U.S. 203 (1997). 3. Blackstone, William. Commentaries on the Laws of England. 1765–1769. 4. Cribbs-Ringer v. Comal Independent School District, No. 25-51045 (5th Cir. May 29, 2026) (order granting summary reversal). 5. Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, 597 U.S. 507 (2022). 6. Lemon v. Kurtzman, 403 U.S. 602 (1971). 7. Mahmoud v. Taylor, 606 U.S. 522 (2025). 8. Mallory v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co., 600 U.S. 122 (2023). 9. McCreary County v. American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky, 545 U.S. 844 (2005). 10. Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District, No. 25-50695 (5th Cir. Apr. 21, 2026) (en banc). 11. Nathan v. Alamo Heights Independent School District, No. 26-257 (U.S. petition for writ of certiorari filed Aug. 17, 2026). 12. Rodriguez de Quijas v. Shearson/American Express, Inc., 490 U.S. 477 (1989). 13. Stone v. Graham, 449 U.S. 39 (1980). 14. Texas Education Code § 1.0041 (2025), added by S.B. 10, 89th Leg., R.S., ch. 955 (2025). 15. U.S. Const. amend. I. 16. West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette, 319 U.S. 624 (1943).