I. Introduction

Incarcerated individuals experience a promise of healthcare by the government that most U.S. citizens do not. This right is given through the Eighth Amendment: “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted.”.1 This may not directly translate into the right to healthcare, but in the Supreme Court case Estelle vs. Gamble (1976), the Court found that the deprivation of healthcare constituted cruel and unusual punishment and therefore is a violation of the Eighth Amendment.2 That being said, within the carceral healthcare system, there are many barriers to access that make it almost impossible to be properly treated for medical issues. This leaves many with the question of whether the Eighth Amendment continues to be violated at large by the U.S. prison system and the actors within it.

II. Understanding the Eighth Amendment

The Eighth Amendment is most famously known as the law that bars cruel and unusual punishment. When thinking of what defines cruel and unusual punishment, it’s important to take two things into consideration: the evolving standards of decency and proportionality. In Trop vs. Dulles (1958), the “evolving standards of decency” were created as the doctrine that determines whether a punishment is cruel and unusual. The Court decided that the amendment “must draw its meaning from the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society.”3 This leaves the definition deliberately vague, considering that what constitutes cruel and unusual under the Eighth Amendment can change over time with public opinion. In the 2000s, over a series of cases, the Court determined a test to define whether a punishment fit within the evolving standards of decency. This includes two parts: objective indicia, which look for legislative enactments and state practices that indicate a national consensus, and independent judicial judgment, which is the court's assessment of whether a punishment is proportionate to human dignity.4 This then introduces proportionality, which ensures that the severity of the punishment must be proportional to the severity of the crime committed.5

III. The Eighth Amendment and Healthcare

Healthcare being a right given to the incarcerated through the Eighth Amendment was decided in the 1976 Supreme Court case Estelle vs. Gamble. While working, Gamble was struck by a 600-pound bale. Over the next three months, Gamble was seen 17 times by medical personnel. That being said he still reported being in mass amounts of pain and filed a lawsuit where he claimed that the inadequate treatment of his injuries constituted cruel and unusual punishment.6 The court found that Gamble’s case didn’t constitute cruel and unusual punishment, but rather poor medical judgment or even malpractice on the doctors involved. Though this still raised questions about the Eighth Amendment, the court decided that the government has an obligation to provide healthcare to incarcerated individuals because a failure to do so could result in suffering which would be inconsistent with the standard of decency.7 This introduced the idea of deliberate indifference, which must take place to violate the Eighth Amendment. Deliberate indifference is decided by a two-prong test which involves proving serious medical needs and proving that prison officials knew of and disregarded the risk.8 For a medical need to be considered serious, courts consider a few factors: whether a doctor would consider the medical need as “important and worthy of comment or treatment”, whether the condition significantly affects daily activities, and whether “chronic and substantial pain” exists.9 A medical need only qualifies under this if it is physical per the Prison Litigation Reform Act.10 Once a serious medical need is proven, then it must be proved that prison officials purposely neglected getting the right help. This can be difficult to pin down, but the official must have known facts that would have proven the medical need, and they must have believed that you were in serious need of help.11 The three most common types of deliberate indifference are: denied or unreasonably delayed access to a physician for diagnosis and treatment; failure to administer treatment prescribed by a physician; and the denial of a professional medical judgment.12 An important caveat is that medical negligence or malpractice, even if it were to happen repeatedly, is not, in itself, unconstitutional and not enough to prove deliberate indifference.13

IV. Barriers within the System

Even though healthcare is a given right to the incarcerated, there are many barriers to access that make it much more likely for deliberate indifference to occur, but also make it more difficult to challenge. The most glaring of these barriers is the grievance system. The Prison Litigation Reform Act requires prisoners to complete the internal grievance process before filing a lawsuit if deliberate indifference is suspected.14 The grievance process is tedious and difficult. In 2023, less than 1% of all medical grievances were granted.15 This is a shockingly low number; to receive medical attention, a grievance must be filed. In the same year, almost half of complaints that were received were rejected due to procedural or formatting errors. Some reasons for rejection have included writing in pencil instead of pen, the incorrect number of copies, misspelling, and more.16 Several grievances get closed instead of rejected or approved; this happens in situations where prison officials find that corrective action is not required.17 In these cases, grievances get saved but no action is done towards answering them. Even with the difficulties of the grievance system, if an inmate is seeking medical attention, they must be seen by a correctional officer who decides if there’s a medical necessity before seeing a nurse and then potentially a doctor.18 On top of this, carceral care comes at a cost to inmates. Emily Wang, MD, MAS, a professor at Yale who specializes in the impact of incarceration on health, explains that inmates may have to pay three dollars or more to be seen by a physician depending on the prison.19 Even then, not all prisoners have jobs. Those who do earn, on average, make between $0.14-0.63/hour for non-industry jobs and $0.33-1.41/hour for correctional industry jobs.20 This means that it can take anywhere from hours to weeks to be able to afford medical care. A 2024 study on financial barriers to care in US prisons found that many incarcerated individuals with health problems don’t receive care, particularly in facilities that charge co-payments for medical care.21 It’s important to note that medical care isn’t the only cost associated with prisons. Inmates are expected to pay for room and board, programming, emails/phone calls, and commissary items.22 This can put inmates in tricky situations where they might have to choose between paying for hygiene necessities like soap or tampons and a doctor's visit.

V. Conclusion

Even with deliberate indifference being a difficult concept to prove, the functioning of the carceral healthcare system has proven inadequate. Of inmates with proven persistent medical problems, 13.9% of federal inmates, 20.1% of state inmates, and 68.4% of local jail inmates had received no medical examination since incarceration.23 Since the Eighth Amendment guarantees a right to healthcare, that number should be zero. The grievance system is made difficult on purpose; it's no coincidence that it was made the only way for inmates to seek medical care and yet serves as the biggest barrier to them doing so. The intricacies of these barriers exist as loopholes for public officials to purposely ignore the medical needs of inmates without fully qualifying as deliberate indifference. Therefore, due to the vagueness of the Eighth Amendment, human rights violations are perpetuated and punishment is prioritized.

Footnotes U.S. Constitution, Amendment VIII. Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976). Trop v. Dulles, 356 U.S. 86 (1958). Nick Wolfram, Rethinking the Fundamentals: Applying The Evolving Standards of Decency Test To The Court’s Evaluation of Fundamental Rights, 51 UC LAW SF CONST. Q. 135 (2024). Proportionality, U.S. CONST. ANNOTATED, Justia, https://law.justia.com/constitution/us/amendment-08/14-proportionality.html (last visited Nov. 2, 2026). Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976). Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976). The Jailhouse Lawyer’s Manual, ch. 23, at 707 (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 11th ed. 2017). Id. at 708. The Jailhouse Lawyer’s Manual, ch. 14, (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 11th ed. 2017). The Jailhouse Lawyer’s Manual, ch. 23, at 710 (Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 11th ed. 2017). William J. Rold, Legal Considerations in the Delivery of Health Care Services in Prisons and Jails, 2 Clinical Practice in Correctional Medicine 520 (2006). Estelle v. Gamble, 429 U.S. 97 (1976). S. 866, 104th Cong. (1995). Christie Thompson, et al., ‘Rejected’: How Federal Prisons Stonewall Grievances and Deny Care for Years, The Marshall Project (June 17, 2026), https://www.themarshallproject.org/2026/06/17/health-federal-alabama-prison-complaint. Id. Id. Hoag Levins, Reviewing The Flaws of U.S. Prisons and Jails’ Health Care System, Leonard Davis Inst. of Health Econ. (March 6, 2023), https://ldi.upenn.edu/our-work/research-updates/the-flaws-of-u-s-prisons-and-jails-health-care-system/. Id. Wendy Sawyer, How much do incarcerated people earn in each state?, Prison Policy Initiative (April 10, 2017), https://www.prisonpolicy.org/blog/2017/04/10/wages/. Emily Lupton Lupez, et al., Health, Access to Care, and Financial Barriers to Care Among People Incarcerated in US Prisons, 184 JAMA INTERN. MED. 1176 (2024), https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2024.3567. Lauren-Brooke Eisen, America’s Dystopian Incarceration System of Pay to Stay Behind Bars, BRENNAN CTR. FOR JUST. (Apr. 19, 2023), https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/americas-dystopian-incarceration-system-pay-stay-behind-bars. Andrew P. Wilper, et al., The Health and Health Care of US Prisoners: Results of a Nationwide Survey, 99 Am. J. Pub. Health 666 (2009).